In response to the declaration made by the Council of Europe that the circumcision of infants is a human rights violation, Knesset Immigration, Absorption and Diaspora Committee chairman Yoel Rozvozov has proposed that Jewish circumcision ceremonies be conducted at Israeli embassies.
"No one can force us and Diaspora Jewry to follow certain religious values and not others. We should be allowed to observe all Jewish customs... If necessary, we will instruct embassies to hold circumcision ceremonies on their territory, which is Israeli sovereign territory." ~MK Yoel RazvozovNote, there is no ban on infant circumcision, yet.
European laws allow certain religious values and forbid others all the time. For example, female circumcision for whatever reason is strictly prohibited, and there is no exemption for religious practice. At this point in time, I'm not exactly sure where European laws stand on the marriage of children to other children, or even to adults. Someone please educate me, are bride burnings allowed in any country in Europe?
But I digress; let's stick to forced genital cutting.
What would be the political ramifications would that immigration ministries from countries where female circumcision is seen as an important cultural or religious rite, were to propose female circumcision ceremonies to be conducted at the embassies of their countries?
For example, female genital cutting is performed in Malaysia, Indonesia, Brunei, Singapore and other countries, as a matter of religious and cultural custom, known there as "sunat."
What if the heads of immigration ministries in those countries were to propose having "sunat" ceremonies at their embassies in Europe?
Yes, I'm sure it sounds very poetic to say that "No one can force us to follow certain religious values and not others; we should be allowed to observe all of our customs."
Does it apply in all cases?
Or just with Judaism when it comes to male infant circumcision?
New York Times - A Cutting Tradition
In theory, children could be taken onto the premises of a sympathetic embassy to have their genitals cut if laws against the practice were introduced in a particular jurisdiction.ReplyDelete
I note however, that here in Australia, when law makers criminalized the genital cutting of females (of all ages) over a decade ago, they were careful to also criminalize any attempt to take a girl to another jurisdiction to have her cut. In Western Australia, for example, the penalty is up to 10 years imprisonment, and up to 20 years imprisonment if the cutting occurs within WA.
That's an astonishing double-standard for boys and girls.Delete